This is a strange story from Grims Faery Tales. Several months back a fellow went wakeboarding in an Idaho lake. His fingers became hung in the line and as the boat powered up, the line cinched, and cut his fingers all over. They sank into the murky deep. Several months later a fisherman, gutting a fish finds a very well preserved human finger inside. One finger print analysis later and the dude has a finger back...only he didn't really want it.
Read the full story.